You would think that a gentile market town like Farnham would be awash with olde tea shoppes, but until the recent opening of Natalie Steward’s Vintage Cake House on Downing Street (previously Henny’s Café) the truth is it’s been a bit of a desert on the tea-and-cake front.
No one has a sweeter tooth than my mother, so as soon as I clocked the new signage and towering cake models in the window we were in the door and settled on the sofa. The decor is not-so-shabby chic with elegant gilt mirrors, candy-floss striped walls and distressed dressers piled high with properly vintage china by Paragon, Royal Winton and others. It’s glamorous, and chintzy without bringing you out in a rash. I especially love that the china is genuinely vintage – rather than modern-trying-to-be-retro – and everything is in amazingly pristine condition.
‘Vintage Tea’ calls to us from the Let Them Eat Cake menu, promising finger sandwiches of your choice from the main menu, plus a fruited scone with jam and clotted cream, and a slice of cake – all washed down with a pot of tea. A little disappointingly they’re out of smoked salmon, but it is approaching last orders. Instead, I go for egg mayonnaise and rocket, while my mother has Wiltshire ham with whole grain mustard.
The pastel vintage sign and cluster of daisy-topped confections on the counter not so subliminally plant cupcakes in my mind, and I’m not leaving without one. Can we substitute cake of the day for cupcakes? Of course, no problem.
Our tea is true to its name, beautifully presented on a cornflower-strewn vintage cake stand. I especially love our heavy basket-weave teapot – with loose leaf tea, naturally. The egg mayonnaise is perfect – light, summery and super fresh; the Wiltshire ham flavoursome and off the bone, both sandwiches filled generously and properly satisfying.
The freshly baked scones are just as good. Only the cupcakes don’t quite live up to their looks. The taste’s there but they’re a little dry and on the heavy side, and mine is over baked at the bottom. But I’m replete with sandwiches and clotted cream and in this setting, with Cole Porter and Billie Holiday gently lulling me into a sugar coma, I can forgive anything. I should also admit to being a hard taskmaster when it comes to cake, having been throughly spoiled by my old schoolfriend Sue McMahon’s incredible award-winning creations. She is not the author of Cupcakes and veteran Cookery Editor of Woman’s Weekly for nothing.
The Vintage Cake House really is a breath of fresh air in Farnham and it’s hard to see how Kiara’s a few doors down can last the course unless it takes a leaf out of their book (good cake – the chocolate ganache ranks among my mother’s top ten best chocolate cakes; deathly atmosphere with unfortunate old people’s home style chairs and off-putting blinds in the window). Morello’s is good for Italian specialities (the desserts, homemade quiches and range of hams, salamis and sausages are excellent) but due to size and seating is really more delicatessen than café. Eat-in prices can be on the hefty side.
As well as reasonably priced bespoke wedding cakes and favours (cakes start at £275), The Vintage Cake House can cater for birthdays, hen parties, baby showers and corporate events.
Best of all, you can throw your very own vintage tea party starting at £14.95 per person with vintage china supplied.
Vintage Tea £7.95 per person (served from midday to 4pm)